7 lakes ranked

Clearest lakes in Indiana

Patoka Lake has the clearest water of the 7 lakes in Indiana with summer clarity measurements: a white Secchi disk lowered into it stays visible to about 5.3 feet. Next come Monroe Lake (4.2 ft) and Cagles Mill Lake (2.3 ft); the murkiest is J. Edward Roush Lake, at 1.9 ft. Each figure is the median of the summer readings (June to September, 2016 on) taken by state agencies and volunteer monitors.

  1. 1 Patoka Lake Dubois County 5.3ftsomewhat murky · eutrophic · 14 readings
  2. 2 Monroe Lake Monroe County 4.2ftsomewhat murky · eutrophic · 90 readings
  3. 3 Cagles Mill Lake Putnam County 2.3ftmurky · eutrophic · 11 readings
  4. 4 Salamonie Lake Wabash County 2.3ftmurky · 13 readings
  5. 5 Cecil M. Harden Lake Parke County 2.2ftmurky · eutrophic · 10 readings
  6. 6 Eagle Creek Reservoir Marion County 2.2ftmurky · eutrophic · 9 readings
  7. 7 J. Edward Roush Lake Huntington County 1.9ftmurky · 8 readings

Questions

What is the clearest lake in Indiana?

Of the lakes we follow, Patoka Lake has the clearest water in summer: a Secchi disk stays visible to about 5.3 feet (median of 14 readings). Then come Monroe Lake (4.2 ft) and Cagles Mill Lake (2.3 ft).

How is water clarity measured?

With a Secchi disk: a white (or black and white) disk about 8 inches wide lowered on a marked line until it disappears from view. The depth where it vanishes is the Secchi depth: the deeper, the clearer the water. We take the median of the readings from June to September since 2016 at the monitoring stations inside each lake, published in the Water Quality Portal (USGS, EPA and the states). A lake needs at least 8 readings over 2 years to be listed.

Why is some lake water murky?

Three things cloud a lake: silt and clay washed in by rivers and rain (the brown water of many southern reservoirs), algae fed by nutrients (green water), and tannins from forests and wetlands (tea-colored water). A muddy reservoir is not necessarily unhealthy; where chlorophyll was measured too, the list shows the nutrient class (oligotrophic is clear and nutrient-poor, eutrophic is rich in nutrients and greener).

Does water clarity matter for fishing?

Yes. In clear water fish see farther and spook easily: anglers fish deeper, use lighter line and natural colors, and do best at dawn, dusk or on cloudy days. In murky water fish stay shallower and find food by sound and vibration, so bright or dark lures and baits that rattle work better. Clarity also sets how deep weeds grow, which is where many fish hold.

Clearest lakes in other states