6 lakes · 1 stocked

Brook Trout lakes in New York Where to catch brook trout in New York, with today’s lake levels

Brook trout, illustration
Illustration: Duane Raver / USFWS · Public domain (USFWS)

6 lakes in New York have brook trout, from fish surveys and catches shared on GBIF and the state’s stocking records. The largest are Cayuga Lake, Lake George and Stillwater Reservoir. The NYSDEC stocked brook trout in 1 of them in the last few years. In New York brook trout usually spawn in the fall, from September to November, when the water reaches 40–49°F.

Spawns in New York
Sep–Nov, at 40–49°F water
Most active in
50–60°F water All fish
Where to look
Cold, clear water near springs and inlets.
License
New York fishing license costs · Regulations

New York lakes with brook trout

All brook trout lakes →
Cayuga Lake · water 55°F Indian Lake Lake George Neversink Reservoir · water 52°F Pepacton Reservoir · water 53°F Stillwater Reservoir

Where the water suits brook trout right now

3 of the 3 lakes with a recent water temperature are at 50–60°F, where brook trout feed most.

Today’s levels

Every New York lake we follow with any record of brook trout, old surveys included, or stocked recently. A lake with a few old records may not hold many today: check the NYSDEC’s fishing reports.

  • Boat ramps
  • Marinas
  • Campgrounds
  • Beaches and swim areas
  • Trails
  • Places to stay
Brook Trout lakes in New York
Lake Size On the shore Level (ft) vs full 7 days
Cayuga Lake Live reading Cayuga County · Largemouth bass, smallmouth bass 42,979 ac
  • 11 boat ramps
  • 19 marinas
  • 6 campgrounds
  • 4 beaches and swim areas
  • 13 trails
  • 24+ places to stay
382.40 — —
Indian Lake Below full Hamilton County 4,255 ac
  • 1 boat ramp
  • 1 marina
  • 3 campgrounds
  • 3 beaches and swim areas
  • 5 trails
  • 4 places to stay
1641.88 −9.13 −0.17
Lake George Live reading Essex County · Crappie, brown trout 28,503 ac
  • 11 boat ramps
  • 38 marinas
  • 14 campgrounds
  • 20 beaches and swim areas
  • 20+ trails
  • 24+ places to stay
319.11 — +0.06
Neversink Reservoir Well below full Sullivan County · Smallmouth bass, brown trout 1,484 ac 1423.19 −16.02 −0.83
Pepacton Reservoir Well below full Delaware County · Brown trout, yellow perch 5,439 ac
  • 3 boat ramps
  • 2 campgrounds
  • 1 trail
1261.82 −16.99 +1.88
Stillwater Reservoir Below full Herkimer County · Yellow perch, smallmouth bass 6,154 ac
  • 1 boat ramp
  • 1 marina
  • 1 campground
  • 3 trails
  • 3 places to stay
1665.73 −13.57 −0.34

Stocked with brook trout by the NYSDEC: Indian Lake

Questions about brook trout in New York

Where can you catch brook trout in New York?

6 New York lakes have brook trout on record or stocked, among them Cayuga Lake, Lake George and Stillwater Reservoir. Cold, clear water near springs and inlets.

When do brook trout spawn in New York?

Usually from September to November, when the water warms or cools to about 40–49°F. The water temperature on each lake page, where there is a sensor or a satellite reading, tells you how close it is.

What water temperature do brook trout bite best in?

About 50–60°F. Right now 3 of the 3 New York brook trout lakes with a recent water temperature are in that range.

Which New York lakes are stocked with brook trout?

The NYSDEC stocked brook trout in Indian Lake in the last few years.

Do you need a fishing license to catch brook trout in New York?

Anglers 16 and older need a New York fishing license, sold online by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Free fishing days: Presidents’ Day weekend, a weekend in late June, National Hunting and Fishing Day (September) and Veterans Day. Size and bag limits can be set lake by lake: check the current regulations.

Other fish in New York

Brook Trout lakes in other states