15 lakes
Pumpkinseed lakes in New York Where to catch pumpkinseed in New York, with today’s lake levels
15 lakes in New York have pumpkinseed, from fish surveys and catches shared on GBIF. The largest are Oneida Lake, Seneca Lake and Cayuga Lake. In New York pumpkinseed usually spawn from May to July, when the water reaches 63–78°F.
- Spawns in New York
- May–Jul, at 63–78°F water
- Most active in
- 68–80°F water All fish
- Where to look
- Shallow weedbeds and docks; nests closer to shore and shallower than bluegill.
- License
- New York fishing license costs · Regulations
New York lakes with pumpkinseed
All pumpkinseed lakes →- Under 45°F
- 45–55°F
- 55–65°F
- 65–75°F
- 75–85°F
- 85°F and up
- No recent reading
Surface water temperature: the lake's own sensor (last 3 days) or a satellite pass on a clear day (last 16 days), on 6 lakes.
Where the water suits pumpkinseed right now
None of the 6 lakes with a recent water temperature is at 68–80°F right now: the water is colder. Fish slow and deep, in the warmest part of the day.
Today’s levels
Every New York lake we follow with any record of pumpkinseed, old surveys included, or stocked recently. A lake with a few old records may not hold many today: check the NYSDEC’s fishing reports.
- Boat ramps
- Marinas
- Campgrounds
- Beaches and swim areas
- Trails
- Places to stay
| Lake | Size | On the shore | Level (ft) | vs full | 7 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cannonsville Reservoir Well below full Delaware County · Smallmouth bass, chain pickerel | 4,546 ac |
| 1125.60 | −23.98 | +3.09 |
| Cayuga Lake Live reading Cayuga County · Largemouth bass, smallmouth bass | 42,979 ac |
| 382.40 | — | — |
| Chautauqua Lake Live reading Chautauqua County · Yellow perch, walleye | 13,209 ac |
| 1306.93 | — | −0.31 |
| Conesus Lake Live reading Livingston County · Walleye, yellow perch | 3,216 ac |
| 816.76 | — | −0.21 |
| Delta Reservoir Live reading Oneida County · Walleye, yellow perch | 2,509 ac |
| 526.89 | — | +0.67 |
| Hempstead Lake Live reading Nassau County · Largemouth bass, bluegill | 130 ac |
| 20.65 | — | — |
| Hinckley Reservoir Well below full Oneida County · Yellow perch | 2,750 ac |
| 1202.78 | −20.86 | +1.45 |
| Keuka Lake Live reading Yates County · Brown trout, lake trout | 11,527 ac |
| 713.08 | — | −0.11 |
| Oneida Lake Live reading Onondaga County · Yellow perch, smallmouth bass | 51,291 ac |
| 369.20 | — | +0.24 |
| Onondaga Lake Live reading Onondaga County · Smallmouth bass, largemouth bass | 2,987 ac |
| 363.32 | — | +0.10 |
| Owasco Lake Live reading Cayuga County · Yellow perch, walleye | 6,765 ac |
| 711.59 | — | −0.06 |
| Saratoga Lake Live reading Saratoga County · Bluegill, crappie | 3,879 ac |
| 201.30 | — | −0.19 |
| Seneca Lake Live reading Seneca County · Yellow perch, largemouth bass | 43,407 ac |
| 443.98 | — | +0.39 |
| Stillwater Reservoir Below full Herkimer County · Yellow perch, smallmouth bass | 6,154 ac |
| 1665.73 | −13.57 | −0.34 |
| Whitney Point Reservoir At or near full pool Broome County · Crappie, walleye | 1,153 ac |
| 973.48 | +0.48 | +0.17 |
Questions about pumpkinseed in New York
Where can you catch pumpkinseed in New York?
15 New York lakes have pumpkinseed on record or stocked, among them Oneida Lake, Seneca Lake and Cayuga Lake. Shallow weedbeds and docks; nests closer to shore and shallower than bluegill.
When do pumpkinseed spawn in New York?
Usually from May to July, when the water warms to about 63–78°F. The water temperature on each lake page, where there is a sensor or a satellite reading, tells you how close it is.
What water temperature do pumpkinseed bite best in?
About 68–80°F. Right now 0 of the 6 New York pumpkinseed lakes with a recent water temperature are in that range; the rest are colder.
Do you need a fishing license to catch pumpkinseed in New York?
Anglers 16 and older need a New York fishing license, sold online by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Free fishing days: Presidents’ Day weekend, a weekend in late June, National Hunting and Fishing Day (September) and Veterans Day. Size and bag limits can be set lake by lake: check the current regulations.