108 lakes · 23 states

Pumpkinseed lakes Where to catch pumpkinseed in the U.S., by state

Pumpkinseed, illustration
Illustration: Duane Raver / USFWS · Public domain (USFWS)

A colorful sunfish with an orange belly and a red spot on its ear flap, common in clear, weedy northern lakes; it feeds on snails and takes small worms readily. We find pumpkinseed in 108 of the lakes we follow, in 23 states; the most are in New York (15), Minnesota (11) and Wisconsin (10).

Most active in
68–80°F water All fish
Spawns at
63–78°F water
Spawning season
South Apr–Jun · Middle May–Jul · North May–Jul
Where to look
Shallow weedbeds and docks; nests closer to shore and shallower than bluegill.

Where the water suits pumpkinseed right now

None of the 13 pumpkinseed lakes with a recent water temperature is at 68–80°F right now: the water is colder. Fish slow, deep and in the warmest part of the day.

Lakes with the most pumpkinseed records

  1. Chautauqua Lake New York · 314 records
  2. Glendale Lake Pennsylvania · 99 records
  3. Oneida Lake New York · 68 records
  4. Tionesta Creek Reservoir Pennsylvania · 68 records
  5. Cayuga Lake New York · 66 records
  6. Conemaugh Lake Pennsylvania · 65 records
  7. Lake Champlain Vermont · 63 records
  8. Loyalhanna Lake Pennsylvania · 60 records

Records are catches and surveys shared on GBIF: many records mean a well-studied lake, not always the best fishing.

Pumpkinseed lakes by state

Lakes with any record of pumpkinseed, old surveys included, and lakes the state stocked recently. A lake with a few old records may not hold many today: check the state’s fishing reports.

New York 15 lakes

Minnesota 11 lakes

Wisconsin 10 lakes

Ohio 9 lakes

Pennsylvania 6 lakes

Michigan 5 lakes

North Carolina 5 lakes

Oregon 5 lakes

South Carolina 5 lakes

Washington 5 lakes

Idaho 4 lakes

Montana 4 lakes

New Jersey 4 lakes

Iowa 3 lakes

New Hampshire 3 lakes

Illinois 2 lakes

Maryland 2 lakes

Massachusetts 2 lakes

Texas 2 lakes

Vermont 2 lakes

West Virginia 2 lakes

California 1 lake

Tennessee 1 lake

Questions about pumpkinseed

What water temperature do pumpkinseed spawn at?

Pumpkinseed spawn when the water warms to about 63–78°F. The water temperature on each lake page, where there is a sensor or a satellite reading, tells you how close it is.

When do pumpkinseed spawn?

Usually Apr–Jun in the South, May–Jul in the middle states and May–Jul in the North. High lakes warm later and run a few weeks behind.

What water temperature are pumpkinseed most active in?

Pumpkinseed feed most actively in water of about 68–80°F. Colder, they slow down and want slower baits; warmer, they move deeper and feed early and late. Right now 0 of the 13 pumpkinseed lakes with a recent water temperature are in that range.

Where do you find pumpkinseed in a lake?

Shallow weedbeds and docks; nests closer to shore and shallower than bluegill.

Which state has the most pumpkinseed lakes?

Of the lakes we follow, New York has the most with pumpkinseed: 15, then Minnesota (11) and Wisconsin (10).

Other fish

All fish →