Top 15 of 24
Best fishing lakes in New York
Lake Champlain, Oneida Lake and Cayuga Lake lead our list of the best fishing lakes in New York. It ranks the top 15 of the 24 that qualify by the game fish on record in each lake, whether the state stocks it, and how easy it is to get on the water: boat ramps, fishing piers, bait shops and guides. Each lake shows today's water level, which decides which ramps and banks you can use.
-
Lake Champlain
On the Vermont line 93.7 ft today
- 25 game fish on record
- 66 boat ramps
- 9 bait shops and guides
- 3 fishing piers
- 276,999 acres
Fish: yellow perch, smallmouth bass, bluegill, northern pike, largemouth bass and others.
Lake Champlain runs north for almost 120 miles from Whitehall, New York, to its outlet at the Richelieu River in Quebec, and for much of that length it forms the border between Vermont and New York.
-
Oneida Lake
Onondaga County 369.2 ft today
- 20 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 13 boat ramps
- 4 bait shops and guides
- 1 fishing pier
Fish: yellow perch, smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, walleye, bluegill and others.
Oneida Lake lies just northeast of Syracuse, bordered by Oneida, Madison, Onondaga and Oswego counties, and it is the largest lake entirely within New York.
-
Cayuga Lake
Cayuga County 382.3 ft today
- 29 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 11 boat ramps
- 4 bait shops and guides
- 42,979 acres
Fish: largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, bluegill, lake trout, yellow perch and others.
Cayuga Lake is the longest of the Finger Lakes, a narrow glacial trough in central New York that runs from Ithaca at its south end north to the marshes near Seneca Falls. Its shores fall in Tompkins, Seneca and Cayuga counties.
-
Chautauqua Lake
Chautauqua County 1,306.9 ft today
- 19 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 10 boat ramps
- 5 bait shops and guides
- 1 fishing pier
Fish: yellow perch, walleye, muskellunge, crappie, largemouth bass and others.
Chautauqua Lake lies in southwestern New York, with Mayville, the Chautauqua County seat, at its north end and Jamestown at its south end. It is the largest inland lake in western New York.
-
Seneca Lake
Seneca County 443.9 ft today
- 13 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 9 boat ramps
- 4 bait shops and guides
- 43,407 acres
Fish: yellow perch, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, rainbow trout, brown trout and others.
Seneca Lake is the largest of New York's Finger Lakes by volume, a long, deep trough of cold water running north from Watkins Glen to Geneva through Schuyler, Yates, Seneca and Ontario counties. It holds roughly half of all the water in the Finger Lakes.
-
Lake George
Essex County 319.0 ft today
- 8 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 11 boat ramps
- 6 bait shops and guides
- 28,503 acres
Fish: crappie, brown trout, lake trout and brook trout.
Lake George is a long, narrow natural lake at the southeastern foot of the Adirondack Mountains in New York, running north from Lake George Village to Ticonderoga.
-
Owasco Lake
Cayuga County 711.5 ft today
- 13 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 2 boat ramps
- 6,765 acres
Fish: yellow perch, walleye, smallmouth bass, chain pickerel, largemouth bass and others.
-
Keuka Lake
Yates County 713.1 ft today
- 7 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 1 boat ramp
- 3 bait shops and guides
- 1 fishing pier
Fish: brown trout and lake trout.
Keuka Lake is the Finger Lake shaped like a Y, lying across Yates and Steuben counties in central New York. Penn Yan sits at its northeast tip, Branchport at the northwest tip and Hammondsport at the south end, and the slopes above the water carry the oldest vineyards in the Finger Lakes.
-
Great Sacandaga Lake
Saratoga County 755.1 ft today
- 3 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 7 boat ramps
- 4 bait shops and guides
- 24,977 acres
Fish: brown trout, crappie and rainbow trout.
Great Sacandaga Lake is the reservoir on the Sacandaga River at the southern edge of the Adirondack Park, spread across Fulton and Saratoga counties with a small reach into Hamilton County. Its broad south end lies northeast of Johnstown and Gloversville.
-
Conesus Lake
Livingston County 816.7 ft today
- 12 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 1 boat ramp
- 3,216 acres
Fish: walleye, yellow perch, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, bluegill and others.
-
Saratoga Lake
Saratoga County 201.2 ft today
- 11 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 3 boat ramps
- 3,879 acres
Fish: bluegill, crappie, largemouth bass, northern pike, smallmouth bass and others.
-
Canandaigua Lake
Ontario County 687.1 ft today
- 7 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 4 boat ramps
- 1 fishing pier
- 10,484 acres
Fish: largemouth bass, brown trout, lake trout and chain pickerel.
5 miles south from the city of Canandaigua toward the village of Naples. It lies in Ontario and Yates counties. The name comes from a Seneca word usually given as the chosen spot. Today the lake is the city's drinking water and a summer home for many Rochester families.
-
Cannonsville Reservoir
Delaware County 23.5 ft below full today
- 9 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 1 bait shop or guide
- 4,546 acres
Fish: smallmouth bass, chain pickerel and brown trout.
-
Whitney Point Reservoir
Broome County 0.4 ft above full today
- 14 game fish on record
- 2 boat ramps
- 1 bait shop or guide
- 1,153 acres
Fish: crappie, walleye, yellow perch, smallmouth bass, chain pickerel and others.
-
Stillwater Reservoir
Herkimer County 13.6 ft below full today
- 8 game fish on record
- Stocked by the state
- 1 boat ramp
- 6,154 acres
Fish: yellow perch, smallmouth bass, brook trout and brown trout.
The top 15 of the 24 New York lakes that qualify.
How this list is made
Lakes are ranked by the number of game fish species on record (GBIF and state stocking reports), stocking by the state in the last three years, boat ramps, fishing piers, bait shops and guides on the shore, the size of the lake and how much people look it up. A lake needs at least three game fish on record to be listed. Nothing here is paid for.
The order comes from our data, not from anyone's opinion or payment, and it changes as the data does. A lake we have little data for can rank lower than it deserves: tell us through the contact form if something is missing.
What is the best fishing lake in New York?
By what our data shows, Lake Champlain comes first, with 25 game fish on record, among them yellow perch, smallmouth bass and bluegill, and 66 boat ramps. Oneida Lake and Cayuga Lake follow. The best lake for you depends on the fish you are after: each lake's fishing page lists every species, the spawning calendar and the fishing times for today.
Which New York lakes are stocked with fish?
Of the lakes in this list, the state has stocked Oneida Lake, Cayuga Lake, Chautauqua Lake, Seneca Lake, Lake George and Owasco Lake and 13 more in the last three years, by the stocking reports we follow. Each lake's fishing page gives the species, numbers and dates.
Do I need a fishing license?
Yes, almost everywhere: anyone 16 or older needs a state fishing license in New York, with a few exceptions such as free fishing days. See what it costs and where to buy it on the fishing license page.
How is this list made?
Lakes are ranked by the number of game fish species on record (GBIF and state stocking reports), stocking by the state in the last three years, boat ramps, fishing piers, bait shops and guides on the shore, the size of the lake and how much people look it up. A lake needs at least three game fish on record to be listed. Nothing here is paid for.
Best fishing lakes in other states
- United States
- Alabama
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Florida
- Georgia
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Virginia
- Washington
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming