25 lakes ranked

Highest lakes in New York by elevation

Stillwater Reservoir sits highest of the 25 lakes we follow in New York, at about 1,667 ft above sea level, followed by Indian Lake (1,640 ft) and Neversink Reservoir (1,398 ft). The lowest-lying is Hempstead Lake, at about 20 ft. Elevations are the water surface at its normal level, rounded, from Wikidata and the HydroLAKES database; a reservoir sits lower when it is drawn down.

  1. 1 Stillwater Reservoir Herkimer County 1,667ftabove sea level · 6,154 acres
  2. 2 Indian Lake Hamilton County 1,640ftabove sea level · 4,255 acres
  3. 3 Neversink Reservoir Sullivan County 1,398ftabove sea level · 1,484 acres
  4. 4 Chautauqua Lake Chautauqua County 1,309ftabove sea level · 13,209 acres
  5. 5 Almond Lake Steuben County 1,263ftabove sea level · 130 acres
  6. 6 Pepacton Reservoir Delaware County 1,257ftabove sea level · 5,439 acres
  7. 7 Hinckley Reservoir Oneida County 1,211ftabove sea level · 2,750 acres
  8. 8 East Sidney Lake Delaware County 1,142ftabove sea level · 205 acres
  9. 9 Cannonsville Reservoir Delaware County 1,132ftabove sea level · 4,546 acres
  10. 10 Schoharie Reservoir Schoharie County 1,115ftabove sea level · 1,015 acres
  11. 11 Whitney Point Reservoir Broome County 961ftabove sea level · 1,153 acres
  12. 12 Conesus Lake Livingston County 817ftabove sea level · 3,216 acres
  13. 13 Great Sacandaga Lake Saratoga County 751ftabove sea level · 24,977 acres
  14. 14 Keuka Lake Yates County 715ftabove sea level · 11,527 acres
  15. 15 Owasco Lake Cayuga County 712ftabove sea level · 6,765 acres
  16. 16 Canandaigua Lake Ontario County 689ftabove sea level · 10,484 acres
  17. 17 Ashokan Reservoir Ulster County 568ftabove sea level · 7,993 acres
  18. 18 Delta Reservoir Oneida County 535ftabove sea level · 2,509 acres
  19. 19 Seneca Lake Seneca County 446ftabove sea level · 43,407 acres
  20. 20 Cayuga Lake Cayuga County 381ftabove sea level · 42,979 acres
  21. 21 Oneida Lake Onondaga County 367ftabove sea level · 51,291 acres
  22. 22 Onondaga Lake Onondaga County 361ftabove sea level · 2,987 acres
  23. 23 Lake George Essex County 318ftabove sea level · 28,503 acres
  24. 24 Lake Ontario Monroe County 243ftabove sea level
  25. 25 Hempstead Lake Nassau County 20ftabove sea level · 130 acres

Questions

What is the highest lake in New York?

Of the lakes we follow, Stillwater Reservoir is the highest, at about 1,667 ft above sea level. Next come Indian Lake (1,640 ft) and Neversink Reservoir (1,398 ft).

How much colder is a high lake?

Air cools about 3.5°F for every 1,000 feet you climb, so a lake at 8,000 feet is often 20°F or more cooler than one near sea level on the same day. Its water warms later in spring, stays cold for swimming even in summer, and freezes earlier. The sun is stronger at altitude and afternoon thunderstorms build quickly in the mountains: start early and get off the water when clouds tower.

Do boat engines lose power at high elevation?

Yes. A gasoline engine without a turbo or supercharger loses roughly 3 to 4% of its power for every 1,000 feet of elevation, because the air is thinner. At 7,000 feet that is about a quarter of its power: boats feel slower and struggle to get on plane with a full load. Many owners fit a lower-pitch propeller for high lakes; check the engine maker’s advice for jetting or fuel settings.

Highest lakes in other states by elevation